Nvidia Shield TV vs. Pro (2015 vs. 2017 vs. 2019)


NVIDIA Shield TV 2015 vs 2017 vs 2019

I own three NVIDIA Shield TV’s: a 2015 Shield TV Pro, a 2017 Shield TV and the 2019 Shield TV “tube.”

It’s hands-down the most impressive streaming device I’ve ever used, complete with all the bells and whistles!

But I’m often asked why I own three of them, and what the differences are between them.

It’s a complicated question. Some of the newer models are missing a few features that came standard with older devices.

So let’s break it down.

NVIDIA Shield Design Changes Since 2015

Most of NVIDIA’s Shields (and their controllers) have an iconic, angular design that really sets them apart from other Android boxes.

Both the 2015 models were the same size, and that carried over to the 2017 Shield Pro. NVIDIA switched things up a bit with the base model Shield 2017 TV, shrinking the device by 40%.

The NVIDIA Shield 2019 TV is smaller yet.

NVIDIA Shield TV 2015 vs 2017 vs 2019 side by side
From left to right: 2015 Shield Pro, 2017 Shield TV and 2019 Shield TV

NVIDIA ditched the angular design for a cylindrical design that looks more like an Amazon Echo than a streaming device. Because of this, some people simply call it the “tube.”

This new form factor isn’t smart like a dongle. In fact, it looks more like a smart home device than anything else. The tube comes with a different power cable than other Shields.

But it’s what’s inside that counts.

NVIDIA Shield CPU: Tegra X1 vs. X1+

In 2015, NVIDIA launched the Tegra X1 chip, and it’s still one of the most powerful chipsets in a streaming device today.

Then, in 2019, they offered an upgrade to NVIDIA’s Tegra X1+: a smaller chip with a faster GPU clock rate as well as lower heat output and power consumption.

To be honest, I don’t see a noticeable speed difference between the 1,267 MHz clock speed of the Tegra X1+ chip compared to the TegraX1’s 1,000 MHz clock speed.

If you have an NVIDIA Shield 2017 and are happy with it, this new chip may not be enough to upgrade.

NVIDIA Shield Storage & Memory

The biggest difference between the 2015 NVIDIA Shield vs the 2017 Shield TV and the 2019 Shield TV is their storage capacity. Each has a basic and Pro model.

The Shield TV Pro cost more, but sported a larger hard drive. However, the size varies depending on the model year.

For example, the 2015 Shield Pro came with a whopping 500GB hybrid hard drive that dwarfed the 16GB solid-state drive of the basic Shield TV. That meant plenty of room to store movies, TV shows, music, or games.

The NVIDIA Shield 2017 had similar offerings.

However, to keep costs down, NVIDIA reduced the size of the 2019 Shield Pro’s storage to just 16GB, and cut the Shield TV’s storage down to 8 GB.

NVIDIA Shield TV ports 2015 vs 2017

Most Shield models, except for the 2017 Shield TV and the 2019 Shield TV Pro, also include a microSD card slot for additional storage.

Every NVIDIA Shield, aside from the 2019 basic model, have USB ports so you can add external storage to your device. However, NVIDIA no longer recommends using USB flash drives on Shield TV’s.

Finally, both of the NVIDIA Shield 2015 models and 2017 Shield Pro include a MicroUSB port.

That’s a lot of external storage options. I go over which external hard drive and micro-USB card I use in my own Shield TV’s in this article.

When it comes to system memory, all NVIDIA Shield TV’s have 3GB, except for the most recent basic model (2 GB).

That means the 2019 Shield TV “Tube” may be good enough if you only want to stream content, but it might not be the best choice for serious gamers.

Media lovers also recommend against the basic model if you want to run a Plex or Emby server on your NVIDIA Shield

Audio\Video: AI Upscaling, Dolby Vision & More

There’s been some pretty major changes to the NVIDIA Shield TV over the years. But many of the best things have remained the same.

Every NVIDIA Shield is compatible with HEVC and VP9 codecs for beautiful 4K pictures at 60 FPS.

AI Upscaling

Older videos look great too, thanks to NVIDIA including upscaling in every Shield.

Upscaling allows you to watch lower-quality videos (720p or 1080p) in 4K, rather than showing the content at a smaller size.

Image: nvidia.com

The 2019 Shield includes a new “AI upscaling”, which NVIDIA describes as employing “a deep learning model predicts a high-resolution image that would downscale to look like the original, low-resolution image.”

Traditional upscaling uses repeating pixels to achieve a similar effect. However, NVIDIA is confident that this new upscaling method produces images that are crisper than ever before.

HDR10+

Finally, the NVIDIA Shield 2019 devices include an upgrade to HDR10+ Dolby Vision, which provides a backward-compatible framework for HDR.

Like with upscaling, older Shields accomplished something similar, through a slightly different method. The older HDR10 standard, included static metadata with encoded color calibration settings to help make the picture look real.

The upgraded HDR10+ allows for frame-by-frame color and brightness adjustments. That means HDR10+ is up to four times brighter than the older standard.

Audio Formats

As you’d expect, every NVIDIA Shield is compatible with a range of audio codecs, including:

  • AAC
  • AAC+
  • eAAC+
  • MP3
  • WAVE
  • AMR
  • OGG Vorbis
  • FLAC
  • PCM
  • WMA
  • WMA-Pro
  • WMA-Lossless
  • Dolby Atmos
  • Dolby TrueHD
  • DTS-X
  • DTS-HD

The Dolby and DTS codecs all support pass-through. That means you can output audio content to a soundbar or audio receiver through your TV even when the receiver is in standby mode.

There’s something for Audiophiles in the 2019 Shield TV too.

Compatible apps like Netflix, Prime. Disney+ and Vudu are now able to use Atmos sound, thanks to the Dolby audio license.

That also allows apps to downmix audio to Dolby Digital 5.1, which is great for older TVs and audio devices. 

Connectivity Hasn’t Changed…Mostly

Every NVIDIA Shield include full gigabit Ethernet, as well as both 2.4GHz and 5GHz band Wi-Fi.

All Shields are also Bluetooth-enabled, but only the NVIDIA Shield 2019 has Bluetooth 5.0. Older versions use the older, slower Bluetooth 4.1.

All NVIDIA Shields come equipped with HDMI 2.0b, which has frustrated some consumers. Many expected the 2019 Shield to upgrade to the HDMI 2.1 spec. That almost doubles HDMI 2.0’s 18 Gbps bandwidth up to 30 Gbps.

It may not matter yet, but at 8k TVs starting to become more common, NVIDIA may be pressured to upgrade in the near future.

Some users, myself included, were frustrated by NVIDIA’s decision to drop the IR receiver with the NVIDIA Shield 2017 model. We’ll get into more detail about that when we talk about the remote controls in the next section.

NVIDIA Shield Remotes: 2015 vs. 2017 vs. 2019

You might be surprised, but some of the most controversial changes to the NVIDIA Shield over the years have been the remote controls!

Here’s another area where Shield TV owners have strong opinions, and I am definitely one of them.

At first glance, the 2015 and 2017 Shield remotes may look the same, but there are some major changes.

Both remotes have identical button layouts, with their voice command buttons, volume touch controls, back, and selection buttons.

They’re both small, sleek and feel amazing to hold in your hand. The differences stop there, however.

The 2015 Shield TV remote (below left) is made from metal, while the 2017 version is plastic.

NVIDIA Shield TV remotes - 2015 vs 2017 vs 2019 side by side

The original remote has a backlit voice button for Google Assistant and a headphone jack on the bottom. Both are missing from the 2017 Shield TV remote.

More importantly, the newer remote ditched the internal rechargeable battery for replaceable CR2032 batteries. Although I love the idea of rechargeable batteries, the battery life degraded quickly over time, so I’m a fan of this move.

The IR blaster on the 2017 remote allows users to power on/off or adjust the volume of other devices, as well as their Shield TV.

The NVIDIA Shield 2019 remote is the most…unique of the three.

Gone is the sleek design of the 2015 and 2017 Shield TV’s.

Instead, we get the triangle remote.

To be fair, the 2019 Shield remote has more buttons, including a dedicated Netflix button, and now features motion-sensing backlighting. You’ll also notice a new menu button and media controls (forward, back, and play/pause).

NVIDIA also replaced the volume slider with actual buttons. The slider was a cool idea, but a bit awkward to use.

Like the 2017 remote, this one is battery-powered. Only this time, you’ll need larger (and heavier) AAA batteries.

The newest Shield remote is backward compatible, so you can use it with either your NVIDIA Shield 2015 or 2017 Shield, if you want to. Personally, I’m not a fan of the new remote and wish there was still a way to purchase one of the older remotes.

NVIDIA Shield Controller: 2015 vs. 2017/2019

If you remember, the original NVIDIA Shield was initially advertised as a mini console.

In fact, the 2015 Shield TV controller was remarkably similar to the original Xbox controller from 2001.  

NVIDIA Shield TV controllers 2015 vs 2017 side by side
2015 Shield controller vs. 2017/2019 Shield controller

Although it’s more comfortable than it looks, NVIDIA really hit the nail on the head with the redesign in 2017.

Beginning with the 2017 Shield TV, NVIDIA trimmed off some of the bulkiness, added rumble support and Google Home compatibility. Thankfully, they kept the USB charging capability and the headphone jack as they were.

The NVIDIA Shield 2017 also introduced IR blasters to the controllers and “always on” listening for voice controls. Users could add a 2017 controller to their 2015 NVIDIA Shield, effectively upgrading the older device

NVIDIA only offered the Gaming Bundle (Shield + Remote + Controller) with the 2017 Shield model. In fact, there’s no update to the controlled for the 2019 Shield models, but you can still purchase a 2017 controller if you want to play games.

However, you may not miss the NVIDIA controller at all.

You can connect Bluetooth controllers, like the PS4, Xbox and several Android controllers, are all compatible with the NVIDIA Shield 2019.

Android TV on NVIDIA Shield

Did you know that the NVIDIA Shield TV is one of the longest officially supported Android devices ever?

It’s true. My NVIDIA Shield 2015 gets the very same updates that my Shield 2019 does.

That’s huge.

Most Android users are lucky to get two years worth of updates, but NVIDIA promises the same Android TV experience on every Shield TV.

And thanks to the impressive hardware, the Shield TV is still outperforming and other Android TV device on the market.

All Shield TV’s support Chromecast 4K and Google Home, as you’d expect. However, Amazon Alexa did get limited support in a recent update.

The original NVIDIA Shield 2015 shipped with Android TV 5, and NVIDIA Shield 2017 models shipped with Android TV 7. Both Shields have since been upgraded to Android TV 9.

Android TV has hundreds of streaming and game apps available on each system. Exclusive to NVIDIA, you can also play games over the cloud via GeForce NOW, for an extra fee, or locally using NVIDIA GameStream.

Starting in 2017, Shields began listing local and remote games together, perhaps to highlight the GeForce Now subscription.

How Much Does the NVIDIA Shield Cost?

Although NVIDIA only officially sells the 2019 Shield TV, you can still find older stock of 2017 Shield’s on Amazon and other retailers.

Official Prices:
2015 Shield TV: $199 for the basic and $299 for the Pro
2017 Shield TV: $199 for the basic and $299 for the Pro
2019 Shield TV: $149 for the basic and $199 for the Pro

It’s worth noting that the pre-owned market may be your best bet. Surprisingly, those used devices’ prices sometimes rival those of newer Shields, especially for the original 300GB 2015 Shield. 

NVIDIA SHIELD Android TV Pro 4K
$237.99
Find on Amazon Learn More
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.
01/21/2021 11:38 pm GMT

Tim Wells

Tim Wells got his first computer at the age of ten and hasn't stopped tinkering ever since. After discovering Android TV boxes in 2013, he created a popular Android PC Review website and guided it to over 8 million pageviews before selling it in 2018. After a brief hiatus from the industry he's back at the helm of AndroidTVNews.com to bring Android TV boxes to the forefront of the streaming world. When he's not writing, he spends as much time as he can with his beautiful wife and his bulldog.

Recent Posts